You might be surprised at the diversity of characters you can run into when it comes to something so simple as a sponge. The reality is, though, that most sponges you’ll come across aren’t worth buying. At Healthy Housekeeping, we’ve worked with every sponge on the market, and here are a few profile sketches of the most common culprits:
PRETTY SPONGES
Pretty sponges, for the most part, are ornamental only. The most common pretty sponges I see are the pastel colored ones from a brand called O-Cel-O. They have soft cellulose sponges and ones with an abrasive side, but the soft ones fall apart pretty quickly and the abrasive ones aren’t very functional. If you’re looking for a super cute and trendy sponge, go for these ones. Just don’t expect them to hold up well if they have to get their hands dirty!
THE MAGIC ERASER
I love the Magic Eraser. I love it so, so, so much – and then it disappoints me every time. You see, the Magic Eraser can clean up just about anything – it just doesn’t last. Even the ones that are advertised to be sturdier are still only a one-clean-stand. Durable or not, though, I still buy them, and I still use them. Even the short-lived affections of such a powerful cleaning tool are worth it to me.
BLUE SPONGES
Lysol and Scotch-Brite both sell blue sponges with a “Non-Scratch” abrasive side. Some of them are curved in shape and some of them have waved contours. In my opinion as an experienced professional cleaner, “Non-Scratch” abrasive sponges are useless. They just don’t work well. I’d much prefer to use a baking soda paste with a rag or the non-abrasive side of a better sponge. I also have another beef with these blue characters – the blue color tends to bleed when used with certain chemicals. Now, granted, I don’t use many chemicals at all with my green cleaning, but all the same, it shows a shocking lack of consideration on the part of the manufacturer to distribute a cleaning tool that can bleed on and even stain certain surfaces when used with common cleaning agents! I avoid these on principle.
“GREEN” SPONGES
Scotch-Brite now markets a “Greener” sponge. At Healthy Housekeeping, we’re all about green products and conservation. There are more things than “green” manufacturing to take into consideration, though, when it comes to conservation. We also need to consider our budgets and the amount of effort required to compensate for potentially less-effective products. Scotch-Brite’s “green” sponges are simply not as effective as other abrasive sponges. They accumulate and retain grease and oils much more quickly than regular abrasive sponges and their scouring capabilities are limited at best. To make these “green” sponges effective, I have to use more work and a lot more of my scouring cleaning solution to compensate for their lack of scouring power.
SCOURING PADS
Scouring pads are good for a few really intense cleaning projects, but for the most part, they’re overkill. These hardcore cleaners scour and scrape not only the surfaces they’re cleaning, but also the person using them. They also get bogged down quickly with grease and oils and lose their functionality.
MY FAVORITE:
My very, very favorite sponges are the yellow cellulose ones with the green scouring backs. Scotch-Brite makes them, but so do most off-brands. Most of them are just as good as the name brands – just be on the lookout for shoddy knock-offs. You can usually tell the sorrier ones by a more washed-out, teal colored scouring pad. These sponges are durable and functional. The soft side is good for cleaning more delicate surfaces like granite, glass and brushed steel, and the scouring side is wonderful for ovens, microwaves, tubs and sinks.
They’re also marketed to be washed in the dishwasher and re-used.
Don’t do it. Just don’t bother. When a sponge is too dirty to use, it’s just plain worn out. No dishwasher can resuscitate it. It’s not going to do the job like it used to. Let it go to pasture where it belongs and start on a new one.
























